home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=91TT2693>
- <link 93XV0015>
- <title>
- Dec. 02, 1991: Pearl Harbor:Day of Infamy
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1991
- Dec. 02, 1991 Pearl Harbor:Day of Infamy
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- PEARL HARBOR, Page 30
- PART 1
- Day of Infamy
- </hdr><body>
- <p>A half-century ago, Japan launched its surprise attack on Pearl
- Harbor, and the world has never been the same since
- </p>
- <p>By OTTO FRIEDRICH -- Research by Anne Hopkins
- </p>
- <p> Warden was just going back for seconds on both hotcakes
- and eggs when this blast shuddered by under the floor and
- rattled the cups It had become very quiet and everybody had
- stopped eating and looked up at each other.
- </p>
- <p> "Must be doin some dynamitin down to Wheeler Field,"
- somebody said tentatively.
- </p>
- <p> -- James Jones, From Here to Eternity
- </p>
- <p> The brass band on the stern of the U.S.S. Nevada kept on
- playing The Star-Spangled Banner for the 8 a.m. flag raising
- even after a Japanese bomber roared overhead and fired a torpedo
- at the nearby Arizona. The torpedo missed, but the bomber
- sprayed machine-gun fire at the Nevada's band and tore up its
- ensign.
- </p>
- <p> "This is the best goddam drill the Army Air Force has ever
- put on," remarked an Arizona sailor standing idly at the
- battleship's rail.
- </p>
- <p> "Air raid, Pearl Harbor, this is no drill," said the radio
- message that went out at 7:58 a.m. from the U.S. Navy's Ford
- Island command center, relayed throughout Hawaii, to Manila, to
- Washington. But there was an even sharper sense of imminent
- disaster in the words someone shouted over the public address
- system on another docked battleship, the Oklahoma: "Man your
- battle stations! This is no shit!" Across the lapping waters of
- the harbor, church bells tolled, summoning the faithful to
- worship.
- </p>
- <p> Almost alongside the Oklahoma, another torpedo hurtled
- through the air. After releasing it, recalled Lieut. Jinichi
- Goto, commander of the Japanese torpedo bombers, "I saw that I
- was even lower than the crow's nest of the great battleship. My
- observer reported a huge waterspout springing up . . .
- `Atarimashita! [It hit!]' he cried."
- </p>
- <p> "I felt a very heavy shock and heard a loud explosion,"
- said the Oklahoma's executive officer, Commander Jesse
- Kenworthy Jr., "and the ship immediately began to list to port.
- As I attempted to get to the conning tower over decks slippery
- with oil and water, I felt the shock of another very heavy
- explosion." Kenworthy gave the order to abandon ship. He barely
- made it over the rising starboard side as the giant battleship
- began to keel over, trapping more than 400 crewmen below decks.
- </p>
- <p> Just as the Oklahoma capsized, a tremendous explosion tore
- open the Arizona. "A spurt of flame came out of the guns in No.
- 2 turret, followed by an explosion of the forward magazine,"
- said a mechanic on the nearby tanker Ramapo. "The foremast
- leaned forward, and the whole forward part of the ship was
- enveloped in flame and smoke and continued to burn fiercely."
- </p>
- <p> In Commander Mitsuo Fuchida's bomber circling overhead,
- antiaircraft fire knocked a hole in the fuselage and damaged the
- steering gear, but Fuchida couldn't take his eyes off the fiery
- death throes of the Arizona. "A huge column of dark red smoke
- rose to 1,000 ft., and a stiff shock wave rocked the plane," he
- recalled years later, when he had become a Presbyterian
- missionary. "It was a hateful, mean-looking red flame, the kind
- that powder produces, and I knew at once that a big magazine had
- exploded. Terrible indeed."
- </p>
- <p> As operational commander of the Japanese attackers,
- Fuchida watched and controlled everything. It was Fuchida who
- had given, exactly at 7:49 a.m. on Dec. 7, 1941, the order to
- attack the strongest naval base in the world: "To! [the first
- syllable of to tsugekiseyo, meaning: Charge!] To! To! To!" It
- was Fuchida who sent back to Tokyo the triumphant signal that
- the attack had caught the Americans by surprise: "Tora!
- [Tiger!] Tora! Tora!"
- </p>
- <p> Now Fuchida led the attack on the Maryland, another of the
- eight battleships berthed at the U.S. Navy's Pacific Fleet
- headquarters. He saw four bombs hurtling toward their target.
- "In perfect pattern [they] plummeted like devils of doom. They
- became small as poppy seeds and finally disappeared just as tiny
- white flashes of smoke appeared on or near the ship."
- </p>
- <p> Pearl Harbor is peaceful now, blue waves in the winter
- sunshine, an occasional toot of harbor traffic. A concrete
- canopy shrouds the rusted wreckage of the Arizona, the remains
- of more than 1,000 American servicemen entombed inside. Her flag
- is still raised and lowered every day on the mast emerging out
- of the quiet water.
- </p>
- <p> The anniversary of the greatest U.S. military defeat, the
- day President Franklin D. Roosevelt called "a date which will
- live in infamy,"* remains a day of death and disgrace, an
- inglorious event, and the spirit of reconciliation still bows
- before gusts of rancor. When President Bush, a World War II
- fighter pilot, indicated that he would attend the Pearl Harbor
- anniversary ceremonies, White House spokesmen stiffly squelched
- any talk of Japanese officials' joining in. So did the Pearl
- Harbor Survivors Association. "We did not invite the Japanese
- 50 years ago, and we don't want them now,'' says the
- association's president, Gerald Glaubitz.
- </p>
- <p> In American mythology, Pearl Harbor still represents, even
- after a half-century, a classic moment of treachery and
- betrayal. Certainly it was a moment of historic surprise, a
- moment when the impossible happened, when warfare suddenly
- spread, for the first and only time in history, to virtually the
- whole world. This was the moment that changed Americans from a
- nation of provincial innocents, not only ignorant of the great
- world but proud of their ignorance, into a nation that would
- often have to bear the burdens of rescuing that world. The same
- cataclysm also changed the Japanese from a people trying to find
- their place on the rim of the great world into a nation that
- would eventually redefine that world and place itself at the
- very center.
- </p>
- <p> The surprise, when it first exploded over Pearl Harbor,
- was shattering, and everyone who experienced it can still
- remember what was going on when the news interrupted that quiet
- Sunday: the Washington Redskins playing the Philadelphia Eagles,
- Arthur Rubinstein as soloist in the New York Philharmonic
- broadcast, or just a visit with friends. Trying to explain the
- national sense of bewilderment, the TIME of that time reflected
- the kind of racism that implicitly underlay the basic American
- attitude. "Over the U.S. and its history," declared the weekly
- newsmagazine, "there was a great unanswered question: What would
- the people . . . say in the face of the mightiest event of their
- time? What they said -- tens of thousands of them -- was: `Why,
- the yellow bastards!' "
- </p>
- <p> As often happens in surprise attacks, however, the
- surprise of Pearl Harbor was largely a matter of national
- illusions. The leaders on both sides fully expected a war,
- indeed considered it inevitable, even to some extent desirable,
- but neither side really wanted to fight unless it had to. Up to
- the last minute, each antagonist thought the other was bluffing.
- </p>
- <p> Japan's navy had already begun planning and training for
- the attack on Pearl Harbor when Emperor Hirohito startled his
- assembled advisers on Sept. 6 by asking an imperial question.
- In the midst of a fervent debate over when and how to go to war,
- the Emperor, who traditionally never spoke during such
- gatherings, suddenly pulled out and read in his high-pitched
- voice a poem by his revered grandfather Emperor Meiji:
- </p>
- <p> All the seas, in every quarter,
- </p>
- <p> are as brothers to one another.
- </p>
- <p> Why, then, do the winds and waves of strife
- </p>
- <p> rage so turbulently throughout the world?
- </p>
- <p> Roosevelt, re-elected to a third term in 1940 after
- pledging that "your boys are not going to be sent to any foreign
- wars," knew that Hirohito was just a figurehead ruler over a
- militarist government dominated by the flinty General Hideki
- Tojo. Still, Roosevelt staked his hopes for peace on a
- last-minute message to the Emperor. "Both of us," Roosevelt
- said, "have a sacred duty to restore traditional amity and
- prevent further death and destruction in the world."
- </p>
- <p> Japanese military censors delayed that message for 10
- hours, so it was almost midnight on Dec. 7 in Tokyo when U.S.
- Ambassador Joseph Grew sped with it to the Foreign Ministry. It
- was past 3 a.m. -- and Fuchida's bombers were within sight of
- Pearl Harbor -- when Foreign Minister Shigenori Togo, in full
- diplomatic regalia, reached the Imperial Palace. He found the
- Emperor listening to his shortwave radio. Togo read him the
- message and then the response that the government had already
- written for him. It said that peace was the Emperor's "cherished
- desire." This would "do well," Hirohito told Togo. The Foreign
- Minister bowed low.
- </p>
- <p> If war between the U.S. and Japan was inevitable, it had
- probably been inevitable for a long time, perhaps as long ago
- as July 8, 1853. That was the day when Commodore Matthew Perry
- sailed his black-hulled steam frigate Susquehanna into Edo Bay
- (now Tokyo Bay) and "opened" Japan at gunpoint, after more than
- two centuries of self-imposed isolation, to American merchants
- and missionaries. Humiliated, the Japanese decided to modernize
- their feudal regime by imitating the barbarian invaders. They
- hired French officers to retrain their soldiers and British
- shipbuilders to create their navy. From the Germans they
- learned the secrets of modern science and from the Americans the
- secrets of modern commerce.
- </p>
- <p> But as Japanese commerce and Japanese emigration
- increased, so did Western talk of a "yellow peril." In 1922 the
- Supreme Court ruled that Japanese immigrants were ineligible to
- become U.S. citizens. The following year it ruled that they
- could be barred from owning American land -- Japanese farmers
- were then growing 10% of California's agricultural produce on
- 1% of its land. In 1924, when Congress imposed national
- immigration quotas, the figure for Japanese was zero.
- </p>
- <p> The deepest conflict between the U.S. and Japan, though,
- was over the future of China, which had been in turmoil ever
- since the collapse of the Manchu Empire in 1911. Though
- Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek claimed that his Canton-based
- Kuomintang represented the entire republic, local warlords ruled
- much of the country, notably the huge northern territory of
- Manchuria. The Japanese, who had blocked a number of Russian
- incursions into Manchuria, were moving in to gain control of the
- region's plentiful coal and iron, which Japan sorely lacked.
- </p>
- <p> The explosive force in the midst of this ferment was
- Japan's fractious Kwantung Army, originally sent to the Kwantung
- Peninsula just east of Beijing to protect Japanese rail and
- shipping interests in Manchuria. After ultranationalist Kwantung
- officers murdered the Chinese overlord of Manchuria, Tokyo
- installed a puppet regime in 1932 and proclaimed the
- independence of what it called Manchukuo. Despite calls for
- sanctions against Japan, outgoing President Herbert Hoover had
- no enthusiasm for a crisis, and the incoming President Roosevelt
- was preoccupied with the onrushing Great Depression.
- </p>
- <p> That left Chiang and his Chinese Nationalists to fight on
- against the Japanese, the growing communist guerrilla forces of
- Mao Zedong and a clutch of surviving warlords. On the night of
- July 7, 1937, came the murky events that constituted the
- long-expected "incident." A Japanese soldier apparently wandered
- off to relieve himself near the Marco Polo Bridge, outside
- Beijing. His comrades, who later claimed they feared he had been
- kidnapped, got into a gunfight with a nearby Chinese Nationalist
- unit, and the fighting soon spread.
- </p>
- <p> The worldwide depression, which partly inspired Japan's
- move into China, left most Americans unable to deal with
- anything beyond their own breadlines and Hoovervilles and,
- Brother, can you spare a dime? To the extent that they worried
- about foreign problems at all, they worried mainly about Adolf
- Hitler, who had seized Austria and the Czech Sudetenland in
- 1938, then demanded western Poland in 1939.
- </p>
- <p> Americans did hear horror stories -- of civilians
- massacred in Japanese air raids on undefended Shanghai and of
- the Rape of Nanking, a month of slaughter that cut down more
- than 200,000 civilians. Roosevelt talked of "quarantining"
- Japan, but American ships went on supplying Tokyo with American
- oil and steel. Times were hard, and business was business.
- </p>
- <p> What came to dominate Japan's overall strategy was the
- impact of Hitler's stunning victories over the Western Allies
- in the spring of 1940. The Dutch army was crushed within a week,
- and Queen Wilhelmina fled to London, leaving the immense wealth
- of the Dutch East Indies (now Indonesia) in the charge of a few
- colonial bureaucrats. France collapsed in a month, and Marshal
- Petain's feeble puppet regime, based in the French resort of
- Vichy, had other worries than French Indochina (Vietnam, Laos
- and Cambodia). Britain, threatened by a Nazi invasion, could
- devote little more than some Churchillian rhetoric to the
- defense of Singapore, Malaya, Hong Kong and Burma.
- </p>
- <p> Japan's Prince Fumimaro Konoye, a serpentine conservative
- who had twice been Premier since 1937, realized the way was now
- clear "to include the British, French, Dutch and Portuguese
- islands of the Orient" in a Japanese commercial empire that
- Tokyo called the Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere. On
- Sept. 27, 1940, Konoye joined the Axis powers, Nazi Germany and
- Fascist Italy, in a formal alliance known as the Tripartite
- Pact. He demanded that Britain shut down the Burma Road, supply
- route for aid to Chiang, and that Vichy accept Japanese bases in
- Indochina for a southern attack on Chiang.
- </p>
- <p> The U.S., the only Western power strong enough to
- retaliate, banned all iron and steel shipments to Japan. "It
- seems inevitable," said Asahi Shimbun, then Japan's largest
- daily, "that a collision should occur between Japan, determined
- to establish a sphere of interest in East Asia . . . and the
- United States, which is determined to meddle in affairs on the
- other side of a vast ocean." Added Yomiuri, another giant
- newspaper: "Asia is the territory of the Asiatics."
- </p>
- <p> Impersonally though the tides of history may seem to flow,
- they now waited on one man, a remarkably squat and
- broad-shouldered man, no more than 5 ft. 3 in. tall. He had been
- born Isoroku Takano, the first name meaning 56, because that was
- the age at which his proud father had been presented with his
- sixth and last son. Later adopted, according to an old custom,
- into a richer family, he acquired a new name: Yamamoto.
- </p>
- <p> Trained as a naval cadet, Yamamoto proudly bore the scars
- he got at 21, when he lost the second and third fingers on his
- left hand during Admiral Togo's great victory over the Russian
- navy at the Strait of Tsushima in 1905. Yamamoto had come to
- know the U.S. as a graduate student at Harvard and as naval
- attache in Washington. And as executive officer of Japan's
- naval flight school, he had learned the new religion of air
- power. He loved poker, bridge and shogi, the Japanese version
- of chess. Said one of his top aides: "He had a gambler's heart."
- </p>
- <p> Now 57, with a gray crew cut, Admiral Yamamoto commanded
- Japan's Combined Fleet, but he disliked the imperial navy's
- cautious strategy. In case of war, its plan was to fall back and
- try to lure the U.S. Pacific Fleet into the Inland Sea between
- the Japanese home islands of Honshu and Kyushu. But as early as
- spring 1940, Yamamoto remarked to one of his officers: "I
- wonder if an aerial attack can't be made on Pearl Harbor."
- </p>
- <p> Others had suggested such a strategy but it had always
- been rejected as too dangerous. Pearl Harbor was too far away,
- too inaccessible, too well defended. Besides, the overall
- strategy of striking south toward Malaya and the Dutch East
- Indies now required all the navy's resources. Yamamoto
- nonetheless began in early 1941 to assemble some trusted
- lieutenants to make plans for Operation Hawaii, which he also
- named Operation Z, after Admiral Togo's historic banner at the
- battle of Tsushima.
- </p>
- <p> One of Yamamoto's key planners was Commander Minoru Genda,
- still only 36, still a hot pilot at heart, first in his class
- at the Etajima naval academy, combat ace over China, leader of
- a daredevil stunt team called Genda's Flying Circus. Genda
- contributed several key ideas: that every available Japanese
- carrier should be assigned to the attack, that it should combine
- dive-bombing, high-level bombing and torpedoes, that the
- attackers should strike at dawn.
- </p>
- <p> Not the least important of his ideas was to recruit a
- cadet classmate named Mitsuo Fuchida, who could train all of
- Yamamoto's pilots and lead them into battle. Fuchida, grandson
- of a famous samurai, was born in 1902, a Year of the Tiger
- ("Tora! Tora!"), so he was 39 when summoned to his mission. An
- ardent admirer of Hitler, he had grown a toothbrush mustache.
- </p>
- <p> The techniques of dive-bombing and torpedo bombing were
- still relatively new, and aerial torpedoes were almost
- impossible to use in water as shallow as Pearl Harbor. Filching
- an idea from a recent British torpedo raid against the Italian
- naval base of Taranto, Genda had technicians create auxiliary
- wooden tail fins that would keep torpedoes closer to the
- surface; others converted armor-piercing shells into bombs. But
- drilling was Fuchida's main task, and all summer his planes
- staged trial runs over Kagoshima Bay in Kyushu, chosen for its
- physical resemblance to Pearl. Only in September did Genda tell
- him, "In case of war, Yamamoto plans to attack Pearl Harbor."
- </p>
- <p> Ironically, Yamamoto didn't want to carry out his own
- plan. But if Japan was going to be forced to fight, he believed
- it should strike first and strike hard, in the hope that a
- demoralized U.S. would then accept a negotiated peace. If he was
- deluded in that hope, he was not deluded about U.S. power. "If
- I am told to fight regardless of the consequences, I shall run
- wild for the first six months or a year," he presciently told
- Prince Konoye in the fall of 1940, "but I have utterly no
- confidence for the second or third year."
- </p>
- <p> By 1940 Japan had installed a pro-Japanese regime in
- Nanking, but U.S. aid enabled Chiang to fight on. Konoye began
- wondering about mediators to end the exasperating war that Tokyo
- insisted on calling the Chinese Incident. Where angels fear to
- tread, in rushed the missionary fathers of the Maryknoll
- Society, who guilelessly assured each side that the other seemed
- ready to talk. And so talks began in Washington in the spring
- of 1941.
- </p>
- <p> Talks is hardly the word. Tokyo's goal was to negotiate a
- victory in China, Washington's goal to negotiate a Japanese
- withdrawal. U.S. Secretary of State Cordell Hull, nearly 70, a
- longtime power on Capitol Hill, was a log-cabin-born Tennessee
- mountaineer who knew little of the Japanese and disliked what
- he knew. He once referred to Tokyo's envoys as "pissants."
- Japan's ambassador, Kichisaburo Nomura, 64, a one-eyed retired
- admiral and former Foreign Minister, was considered a moderate
- and so was mistrusted in Tokyo. It did not help that Hull had
- a speech difficulty, while Nomura was partially deaf.
- </p>
- <p> Hardly had the talks begun when the Japanese, having
- already seized a number of bases in northern Vietnam, suddenly
- occupied the south in July 1941. That threatened not only the
- back route to China but British control of Malaya and Burma (now
- Myanmar). Roosevelt retaliated by freezing all Japanese assets
- and placing an embargo on all trade in oil, steel, chemicals,
- machinery and other strategic goods. (The British and Dutch soon
- announced similar embargoes.) At the same time, he announced
- that General Douglas MacArthur, the retired Chief of Staff now
- luxuriating in the Philippines, was being recalled to active
- military duty and financed in mobilizing 120,000 Filipino
- soldiers. (Roosevelt had made another significant move that
- spring, when he shifted the Pacific Fleet's headquarters from
- San Diego to Pearl Harbor.)
- </p>
- <p> Roosevelt's embargo was a devastating blow, for Japan
- bought more than half its imports from the U.S. The Japanese
- military leaders were determined to fight. When they met with
- the Cabinet on Sept. 3, they insisted on an October deadline for
- Konoye's diplomatic efforts. The Prince asked for a meeting with
- Roosevelt, but Hull was opposed, and Roosevelt, preoccupied with
- the increasing likelihood of war with Hitler, never answered.
- Konoye resigned on Oct. 16. Tojo, a Kwantung Army veteran who
- was then War Minister, became Premier.
- </p>
- <p> Though Japan's military leaders had decided on war, they
- had not yet agreed to a surprise attack on Pearl Harbor.
- Yamamoto was adamant: "Japan must deal the U.S. Navy a fatal
- blow at the outset of the war. It is the only way she can fight
- with any reasonable prospect of success." But war games
- suggested that an attacking fleet would be spotted and badly
- mauled. As late as October, Yamamoto learned that the staff
- admirals, determined to concentrate on the drive into Southeast
- Asia, wanted to take away two or three of his six carriers. The
- First Air Fleet's own commander, Vice Admiral Chuichi Nagumo,
- supported that decision. "The success of our surprise attack on
- Pearl Harbor," Nagumo predicted dolefully, "will prove to be the
- Waterloo of the war to follow." Yamamoto sent an aide to inform
- the navy's high command that if his Pearl Harbor plan was
- rejected, "he will have no alternative but to resign, and with
- him his entire staff." Yamamoto got his way.
- </p>
- <p> The military set a new target date of Dec. 8 (Dec. 7 in
- Hawaii), and the Emperor and his military chiefs formally
- approved Yamamoto's attack plan on Nov. 3. But the Foreign
- Ministry instructed Ambassador Nomura and Special Envoy Saburo
- Kurusu to make "a final effort" in Washington.
- </p>
- <p> On Nov. 17, Yamamoto visited his training base in Saeki
- Bay to bid his men farewell. "Japan has faced many worthy
- opponents in her glorious history -- Mongols, Chinese,
- Russians," Yamamoto said, "but in this operation we will meet
- the strongest opponent of all. I expect this operation to be a
- success." Genda, Fuchida and other officers joined him in eating
- surume (dried cuttlefish) for happiness and kachiguri (walnuts)
- for victory. Near portable Shinto shrines, they toasted the
- Emperor with sake and shouted, "Banzai!"
- </p>
- <p> It took Nagumo's fleet five days to reach the rendezvous
- point at Hitokappu Bay in the Kuriles just north of Japan's main
- islands. Fog swirled over the desolate outpost, and snow fell
- intermittently as the fleet steamed eastward at dawn on Nov. 26.
- </p>
- <p> The armada boasted six carriers, led by Nagumo's flagship,
- the Akagi, 400 warplanes, two battleships, two cruisers, nine
- destroyers and a dozen other surface ships. At an average 13
- knots, refueling daily, the attack fleet pursued a course 3,500
- miles through the empty expanse of the North Pacific. Its orders
- provided that "in the event an agreement is reached in the
- negotiations with the United States, the task force will
- immediately return to Japan," but nobody expected that to
- happen.
- </p>
- <p> The envoys made their "final effort" on Nov. 20,
- presenting to Hull an unyielding proposal on which Foreign
- Minister Togo said "no further concessions" could be made.
- Nomura noted that this was an inauspicious day -- "They call it
- Thanksgiving" -- but he dutifully delivered the message. It said
- the U.S. must restore trade to pre-embargo levels, provide oil
- from the Dutch East Indies and not interfere with Japan's
- "efforts for peace" in China.
- </p>
- <p> Hull's answer, just as forceful, said the U.S. oil embargo
- would continue, and demanded that Japan "withdraw all military,
- naval, air and police forces from China and from Indochina." He
- handed it to the envoys on Nov. 26, the day Nagumo's fleet left
- Hitokappu Bay for Pearl Harbor. Hull did not know that, since
- the fleet was under total radio silence, but he did know from
- intercepted messages that another Japanese war fleet had passed
- Formosa on its way toward Indochina or Malaya. "We must all
- prepare for real trouble, possibly soon," Roosevelt cabled
- Churchill.
- </p>
- <p> The War Department then sent Hawaii and other outposts an
- important but significantly ambiguous "war warning."
- "Negotiations with Japan appear to be terminated to all
- practical purposes," said this Nov. 27 message over the
- signature of Chief of Staff George Marshall. "Japanese future
- action unpredictable but hostile action possible at any moment
- . . . You are directed to undertake such reconnaissance and
- other measures as you deem necessary, but these measures should
- be carried out so as not repeat not to alarm civil population
- or disclose intent. Report measures taken." Hawaii's commander,
- Lieut. General Walter Short, not a man of broad vision, reported
- back that he was taking measures to avert sabotage -- parking
- his aircraft close together and keeping all ammunition safely
- locked up. Since Washington did not specify a threat to Pearl
- Harbor, Short felt he had done his duty, just as Marshall felt
- he had done his.
- </p>
- <p> The Navy Department sent an even stronger message to its
- top commanders, specifically including the Pacific Fleet chief
- in Pearl Harbor, Admiral Husband Kimmel: "This dispatch is to
- be considered a war warning. Negotiations with Japan . . . have
- ceased, and an aggressive move by Japan is expected within the
- next few days." Kimmel, 60, a hard-driving disciplinarian who
- had held his command less than a year, took the warning as "no
- more than saying that Japan was going to attack someplace."
- </p>
- <p> Kimmel and Short were only too aware that Washington was
- concentrating on Hitler's victories in Russia and his
- submarines' ravages of Atlantic shipping. Though Chief of Naval
- Operations Harold Stark acknowledged to Kimmel that his Pacific
- Fleet was weaker than the Japanese forces arrayed against it,
- he not only turned aside Kimmel's request for two new
- battleships but took away three he had, plus one of his four
- carriers, to help fight the Battle of the Atlantic.
- </p>
- <p> Roosevelt's assertive strategy against Japan was largely
- a bluff, backed by inadequate armed forces and inadequate funds.
- Washington theoreticians saw the Philippines as a check to any
- Japanese move southward. MacArthur overconfidently promised that
- he would soon have 200,000 Filipinos ready for combat, and the
- War Department began in the summer of 1941 to ship him the first
- of a promised 128 new B-17 Flying Fortresses. By April 1942,
- said Marshall, that would represent "the greatest concentration
- of heavy-bomber strength anywhere in the world," able to
- interdict any Japanese assault on Southeast Asia and mount
- "incendiary attacks to burn up the wood and paper structures of
- the densely populated Japanese cities."
- </p>
- <p> Perhaps the greatest single cause of American complacency
- in the Pacific was the fact that the U.S. military's Operation
- Magic had deciphered Japan's sophisticated Purple diplomatic
- code in 1940. But that triumph had its drawbacks. U.S.
- intelligence officials had to sift through so much trivia that
- they failed to react to some important messages, such as a Tokyo
- request to its Hawaiian consulate for the exact location of all
- ships in Pearl Harbor. Also, the code breaking was kept secret
- even from some key officials. While the British were plugged
- into Magic, and MacArthur too, Kimmel and Short were not.
- </p>
- <p> Ironically, the Nazis warned the Japanese that their codes
- might have been broken, but Tokyo refused to believe the
- Americans were smart enough for such a feat. Just as ironically,
- while U.S. code breakers knew of the Japanese warships heading
- for Southeast Asia, Nagumo's radio silence meant that his
- carriers heading for Pearl Harbor simply disappeared. On Dec.
- 2, Kimmel's intelligence officer confessed that nothing had been
- heard from the Japanese carriers for about two weeks.
- </p>
- <p> "What!" said Kimmel. "You don't know where [they] are?"
- </p>
- <p> "No, sir, I do not. I think they are in home waters, but
- I do not know where they are."
- </p>
- <p> "Do you mean to say that they could be rounding Diamond
- Head, and you wouldn't know it?"
- </p>
- <p> "I hope they would be sighted before now."
- </p>
- <p> And the Americans could intercept but not understand a
- message Yamamoto sent his fleet on Dec. 2: "Climb Mount
- Niitaka." That meant "Proceed with the attack."
- </p>
- <p> One thing that the code breaking did tell Washington was
- Tokyo's answer to Hull's last proposal. Before the original even
- reached the Japanese envoys, a messenger brought an intercepted
- version to Roosevelt in his White House study after dinner on
- Dec. 6. The President read it carefully for about 10 minutes,
- then said to his closest aide, Harry Hopkins, "This means war."
- </p>
- <p> Roosevelt tried to call Admiral Stark, but he was at a
- revival of Sigmund Romberg's Student Prince; the President
- didn't want him paged at the theater lest that cause "undue
- alarm." When Roosevelt did finally reach him shortly before
- midnight, the Navy chief said, according to his later
- recollection, that the message was not "something that required
- action." After all, Stark testified, warnings had already gone
- out that Japan was "likely to attack at any time in any
- direction."
- </p>
- <p> That same Saturday night was the standard party night in
- Pearl Harbor, not orgiastic but convivial. Hundreds of soldiers
- and sailors from Schofield Barracks and Hickam and Kaneohe
- converged as usual on Waikiki Beach to see what was going on at
- Bill Leader's bar, the Two Jacks or the Mint. Tantalizing
- Tootsies was the name of the variety show at the Princess.
- </p>
- <p> Kimmel attended a staid dinner party at the Halekulani
- Hotel and left early. He had a golf date the next morning with
- General Short, who went to a charity dance at the Schofield
- Barracks and also left early. As he rode along the coast
- highway, Short admired the lights of Pearl Harbor glowing below
- him. "Isn't that a beautiful sight?" he said. "And what a target
- it would make!"
- </p>
- <p> Though the final Japanese note said nothing about war or
- Pearl Harbor, it was not quite complete -- it contained 13 parts
- and said another would soon follow. The 14th and last part
- reached Washington the morning of Dec. 7. It notified the U.S.
- that "it is impossible to reach an agreement through further
- negotiations." An accompanying message instructed Nomura to
- deliver the note "at 1 p.m. on the 7th, your time."
- </p>
- <p> Nobody in Washington knew Hirohito had asked that the
- warning be delivered before the attack -- 1 p.m. in Washington
- was 7:30 a.m. in Hawaii -- but an Army intelligence officer,
- Colonel Rufus Bratton, guessed as much. Bratton telephoned
- Marshall at his quarters at Fort Myers, Va., but he was out
- riding. More than an hour later, about 10:30 a.m., Marshall
- called back and said he was coming to his office shortly. About
- the same time, Hull was meeting with War Secretary Henry L.
- Stimson and Navy Secretary Frank Knox. "Hull is very certain
- that the Japs are planning some deviltry," Stimson recorded in
- his diary, "and we are all wondering when the blow will strike."
- </p>
- <p> Fuchida woke at 5 a.m. As he told American military
- historian Gordon Prange, he put on red underwear and a red shirt
- so that if he was wounded, his men would not be distracted by
- the sight of his blood. At breakfast, one of his lieutenants
- said, "Honolulu sleeps."
- </p>
- <p> "How do you know?" asked Fuchida.
- </p>
- <p> "The Honolulu radio plays soft music. Everything is fine."
- </p>
- <p> At 5:50 a.m. Nagumo's fleet reached the takeoff point,
- about 220 miles north of Pearl Harbor. The six carriers turned
- east into a brisk wind and increased speed to 24 knots.
- Nagumo's flagship was flying the celebrated Z pennant that
- Admiral Togo had flown at Tsushima in 1905. The flight decks
- tilted more than 10 degrees, and the wind whipped spray over
- them.
- </p>
- <p> "We could hear the waves splashing against the ship with
- a thunderous noise," Fuchida recalled later. "Under normal
- circumstances, no plane would be permitted to take off in such
- weather . . . There were loud cheers as each plane rose into the
- air." Once up, the pilots circled overhead until all 183 planes
- assigned to the first wave were airborne. At 6:15 Fuchida gave
- a signal, then led the way south.
- </p>
- <p> At almost that very hour -- around 11:30 a.m. in
- Washington -- Marshall arrived at his office and read the
- ominous words Bratton had brought him. He asked the officers
- assembled there what they thought it meant. All expected an
- imminent Japanese attack -- somewhere. Marshall recalled that
- every major U.S. base had been warned of that more than a week
- earlier. Bratton and others urged a new warning. Marshall
- scrawled a message reporting the 1 p.m. meeting and added, "Just
- what significance the hour set may have we do not know, but be
- on alert accordingly."
- </p>
- <p> Bratton rushed the message to the War Department signal
- center, where Marshall's scrawl had to be retyped for
- legibility. The message went to several points within a few
- minutes, but because of atmospheric difficulties, the copy for
- Hawaii went by commercial wireless. It reached Honolulu at 7:33
- a.m. and ended in a pigeon hole, awaiting a motorcycle messenger
- to deliver it.
- </p>
- <p> Fuchida's bombers had to fly blind over dense banks of
- clouds, so they homed on the Honolulu commercial radio station
- KGMB. Over his receiver, Fuchida heard soothing music, then a
- weather report: "Partly cloudy . . . over the mountains. Cloud
- base at 3,500 ft. Visibility good." Fuchida flew on.
- </p>
- <p> To save money and fuel and manpower, the Pearl Harbor
- authorities had recently canceled weekend reconnaissance
- flights. But they had acquired some new radar equipment, though
- the National Park Service strongly objected to towers being
- installed on scenic mountaintops.
- </p>
- <p> Two trainees operating a mobile radar unit at Opana, on
- Oahu's northern coast, were about to shut down when their watch
- ended at 7 a.m. Suddenly, Private Joseph Lockard noticed a large
- blip -- "probably more than 50" planes -- approaching southward
- from about 130 miles away. On the phone to Fort Shafter,
- Lockard reported to Lieut. Kermit Tyler "the largest [flight]
- I have ever seen on the equipment." The inexperienced Tyler
- figured that the planes must be a flight of the new B-17s
- expected from California. He told Lockard, "Don't worry about
- it."
- </p>
- <p> As Fuchida's bombers neared Oahu, the defenders of Pearl
- Harbor got the last of their many warnings. Just outside the
- harbor, the U.S. destroyer Ward spotted an intruding submarine
- at 6:30 a.m. and opened fire from 50 yds. away. As the sub began
- diving, the Ward finished it off with depth charges. Lieut.
- William Outerbridge's report of his action was still ricocheting
- around headquarters when Fuchida arrived overhead.
- </p>
- <p> "What a majestic sight," he said to himself as he counted
- the vessels lined up in Battleship Row in the dawn's early
- light. He pulled the trigger on his flare gun. That was supposed
- to signal the slow-moving torpedo bombers to take advantage of
- the surprise and strike first. But Fuchida's fighter pilots
- missed his signal to provide cover, so he fired again for the
- dive bombers to begin, and then the Japanese all attacked at
- once. Even when they made mistakes, it seemed that nothing
- could go wrong.
- </p>
- <p> Within minutes, Pearl Harbor was pandemonium: explosions,
- screams, tearing steel, the rattle of machine guns, smoke, fire,
- bugles sounding, the whine of diving airplanes, more explosions,
- more screams. With Battleship Row afire, Fuchida's bombers
- circled over the maze of Pearl Harbor's docks and piers,
- striking again and again at the cruisers and destroyers and
- supply ships harbored there.
- </p>
- <p> Other Japanese bombers swarmed over Hawaii's military
- airfields, Hickam and Wheeler, Kaneohe and Ewa. Dive-bombing and
- strafing the American planes neatly parked on the runways, they
- quickly won control of the sky. They wrecked hangars,
- warehouses, barracks -- as well as the Hickam Field chapel and
- the enlisted men's new beer hall, the Snake Ranch. And in the
- midst of all this, a rainbow appeared over Ford Island.
- </p>
- <p> To many of the Americans, the whole morning had a
- dreamlike unreality. Disbelief had been the overwhelming first
- reaction -- this couldn't be happening, it was a trick, a drill,
- a silly rumor, a prank -- disbelief and then pain and then
- anger, and still disbelief.
- </p>
- <p> Admiral Kimmel was preparing for his golf game with
- General Short when an officer phoned him with the news that
- Japanese planes were attacking his fleet. The admiral was still
- buttoning his white uniform as he ran out of his house and onto
- the neighboring lawn of his chief of staff, Captain. John Earle,
- which had a fine view of Battleship Row. Mrs. Earle said later
- that the admiral's face was "as white as the uniform he wore."
- </p>
- <p> "The sky was full of the enemy," Kimmel recalled. He saw
- the Arizona "lift out of the water, then sink back down -- way
- down." Mrs. Earle saw a battleship capsize.
- </p>
- <p> "Looks like they've got the Oklahoma," she said.
- </p>
- <p> "Yes, I can see they have," the admiral numbly responded.
- </p>
- <p> General Short, who couldn't see the explosions, bumped
- into an intelligence officer and asked, "What's going on out
- there?"
- </p>
- <p> "I'm not sure, general," said Lieut. Colonel George
- Bicknell, "but I just saw two battleships sunk."
- </p>
- <p> "That's ridiculous!" said Short.
- </p>
- <p> Down on Battleship Row, Fuchida's bombers kept pounding
- the helpless battlewagons. The West Virginia took six
- torpedoes, then two bombs. One large piece of shrapnel smashed
- into the starboard side of the bridge and tore open the stomach
- of the skipper, Captain Mervyn Bennion. A medic patched up the
- dying man's wound, and a husky black mess steward, Doris Miller,
- who had once boxed as the ship's heavyweight champion, helped
- move the stricken captain to a sheltered spot.
- </p>
- <p> Fire and smoke swirled around the bridge. Bennion told his
- men to leave him; they ignored him. He asked them how the
- battle was going; they told him all was well. After Bennion
- died, an officer told Miller to feed ammunition into a nearby
- machine gun. Like other blacks in the Navy of 1941, Miller had
- not been trained for anything but domestic chores, but he soon
- took charge of the machine gun and started firing away. A young
- ensign recalled later that it was the first time he had seen
- Miller smile since he last fought in the ring.
- </p>
- <p> Caught by surprise, and then often finding all ammunition
- neatly locked away, the defenders hacked away the locks and
- fought back with any weapons at hand -- machine guns, rifles,
- pistols. This usually achieved nothing, but there were some
- surprises. At Kaneohe Naval Air Station on the east coast of
- Oahu, a flight of Mitsubishi Zeroes was strafing the hangars
- when a sailor named Sands darted out of an armory and fired a
- burst with a Browning automatic rifle.
- </p>
- <p> "Hand me another BAR!" shouted Sands. "I swear I hit that
- yellow bastard!"
- </p>
- <p> Japanese Lieut. Fusata Iida turned to strafe Sands, but
- the sailor fired another BAR clip, then ducked the bullets that
- pocked the armory's wall. As Iida's Zero climbed again,
- gasoline began streaming from his fuel tank. Before takeoff,
- Iida had said that any pilot whose engine failed should crash
- his plane into the enemy, so now he turned for a last attack.
- For one incredible minute, the two enemies faced and fired at
- each other, Iida from his crippled Zero, Sands with his BAR.
- Then the Zero nosed into a highway and smashed into pieces.
- </p>
- <p> As Admiral Kimmel stood near a window, a spent machine-gun
- bullet smashed the glass and hit him lightly in the chest.
- Kimmel -- who would soon, like General Short, be dismissed from
- his command -- picked up the bullet. To an aide, he observed,
- "It would have been merciful had it killed me."
- </p>
- <p> In Washington the disbelief was just as overwhelming. "My
- God, this can't be true, this must mean the Philippines," said
- Secretary Knox on hearing the news. "No, sir," said Admiral
- Stark, "this is Pearl."
- </p>
- <p> Knox called Roosevelt, and Roosevelt called Hull, who was
- supposed to meet Nomura and Kurusu at 1 p.m. But the envoys had
- trouble getting the message from Tokyo decoded and retyped and
- asked for a delay, so it was 2:05 before they seated themselves,
- all unknowing, in Hull's antechamber. Hull, who had already
- read their message and knew about the raid on Pearl Harbor as
- well, made a pretense of reading the document, then lashed out
- at the luckless envoys. "In all my 50 years of public service,"
- he declared, "I have never seen a document that was more
- crowded with infamous falsehoods and distortions." When Nomura
- tried to answer, Hull raised a hand to cut him off, then showed
- him to the door.
- </p>
- <p> Fuchida's surprise attack lasted only about half an hour.
- Then, after a short lull, a second wave of 171 more planes
- roared in. By now the Americans were on the alert and firing at
- anything in sight. Twenty planes flying in from maneuvers with
- the Enterprise came under heavy American fire; two were shot
- down.
- </p>
- <p> The battered Nevada (its band having finished The
- Star-Spangled Banner) managed to get up enough steam to proceed
- majestically out into the channel to the sea. Despite a gaping
- hole in its bow, its guns were firing, and its torn flag flew
- high. As it edged past the burning Arizona, three of that doomed
- ship's crewmen swam over, clambered aboard and manned a
- starboard gun.
- </p>
- <p> "Ah, good!" the watching Fuchida said to himself as he saw
- the slow-moving Nevada. At his signal, all available bombers
- attacked in an effort to sink it and block the channel to the
- sea. Bombs ignited huge fires in the ship's bow. It escaped
- total destruction only by deliberately running aground.
- </p>
- <p> More fortunate -- indeed kissed by fortune -- were Army
- pilots George Welch and Kenneth Taylor, who had gone from a
- dance at the Wheeler Officers' Club to an all-night poker game.
- They were still in formal dress at 8 a.m. when they saw the
- first Japanese planes open fire overhead. Under strafing fire,
- Taylor's car careened back to the P-40 fighters at Haleiwa
- Field. Taking off, the two went looking for Japanese planes and
- soon found them over Wheeler.
- </p>
- <p> "I got in a string of six or eight planes," Taylor
- recalled. "I was on one's tail as we went over Waialua . . . and
- there was one following firing at me . . . Lieut. Welch, I
- think, shot the other man down." Welch's version: "We took off
- directly into them and shot some down. I shot down one right on
- Lieut. Taylor's tail."
- </p>
- <p> Landing only for more fuel and ammunition, the two
- sleepless lieutenants set off for the Marine base at Barber's
- Point. "We went down and got in the traffic pattern and shot
- down several planes there," said Taylor, who suffered a severe
- arm wound. "I know for certain I shot down two planes or perhaps
- more; I don't know." Official records credited the two of them
- with downing seven planes, almost one-quarter of all Japanese
- losses.
- </p>
- <p> The great attack was really fairly short. The first
- bombers returned to their carriers just after 10 a.m., scarcely
- two hours after they descended on Battleship Row. Fuchida
- lingered to observe and photograph the damage and was the last
- to return to Nagumo's fleet. It was still only noon.
- </p>
- <p> Fuchida and Genda argued fiercely for renewing the attack.
- The oil-storage tanks had not been hit, and the raiders had not
- found any of Kimmel's three carriers (the Lexington and
- Enterprise were at sea, the Saratoga undergoing repairs). But
- Admiral Nagumo, who had mistrusted the plan from the start, felt
- he had accomplished his mission and saw no reason to risk his
- fleet any further. Back in Japan, Yamamoto strongly disapproved
- of Nagumo's decision to withdraw but accepted the tradition that
- such decisions are left to the combat commander on the scene.
- </p>
- <p> Long after the Japanese had left, Pearl Harbor
- reverberated with reports of enemy invasions, parachute landings
- and other nightmares. Jittery defenders fired wildly at anything
- that moved. A fishing boat returning with the day's catch was
- shot to pieces.
- </p>
- <p> On the capsized hull of the Oklahoma, Commander Kenworthy
- strode up and down for hours listening for raps and banging from
- the men trapped inside. Some survivors were finally pulled to
- safety through holes cut in the hull, but others drowned in the
- water rushing through the openings. Kenworthy wouldn't leave
- until the last of 32 survivors had been saved. By then it was
- Monday afternoon. Six sailors caught inside the West Virginia
- died just before Christmas -- after two weeks of incarceration.
- </p>
- <p> In terms of casualties and destruction, this was one of
- the most one-sided battles in history. The U.S. lost 2,433
- killed (about half of them on the Arizona) and 1,178 wounded.
- The Japanese, who had expected to sacrifice as much as one-third
- of their force, lost 55 airmen, nine crewmen aboard five
- minisubs and approximately 65 on one sunken submarine. The U.S.
- lost 18 surface warships, sunk or seriously damaged; the
- Japanese none. The U.S. lost 188 planes destroyed and 159
- damaged; the Japanese lost 29. Yet three of the five wrecked
- U.S. battleships (the California, Nevada and West Virginia) were
- eventually restored to service, and all the lost warplanes were
- eventually replaced -- more than replaced -- by the bombers that
- struck Tokyo and Hiroshima.
- </p>
- <p> If Pearl Harbor seemed an American disaster, it proved a
- Japanese disaster as well. Churchill knew that when he gloated
- at the news: "So we had won after all!" So did Stimson, who felt
- "relief . . . that a crisis had come in a way which would unite
- all our people." So did Admiral Yamamoto, when he predicted
- that he would run wild for only a year. Pearl Harbor united
- Americans in rage and hatred, and thus united, powerful and
- determined, they would prove invincible.
- </p>
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-